Buy the ESPRO P3 (32 oz, Black) if you want the clean-cup everyday upgrade with the largest brew in this pair and the lower observed ticket; buy the Fellow Clara (24 oz, Matte Black) if you want vacuum-insulated heat retention with an enhanced-mesh design press and you accept a smaller brew at a higher observed ticket. The P3 is the filtration pick: the maker page describes a patented dual micro-filter system with Air Lock Technology that stops extraction after the plunge, a 32 oz brew capacity with a 24 oz minimum, and a transparent extra-thick borosilicate glass carafe in a BPA, BPS and phthalate-free plastic frame. The Clara is the heat-retention pick: the maker page describes a double-wall vacuum body, enhanced mesh filtration, an all-direction pour lid, ratio lines with an included agitation stick, and a non-stick PTFE-coated interior that is PFOA-free. On 09/16/2026 the exact P3 variant was orderable on Amazon US at $39.94, In Stock, sold by ESPRO Inc. and shipped from Amazon Fulfillment with delivery Saturday Sep 19, and the exact Clara variant was orderable at $99.95, sold by Fellow Industries Inc. and shipped from Amazon Fulfillment with delivery Monday Oct 5 as shown.
Choose by your situation
| Situation | Model to consider | Main tradeoff |
|---|---|---|
| You brew 4+ cups at once or serve two big mugs and want grit-free cups | ESPRO P3, 32 oz | Glass carafe without a vacuum-insulation claim in the observed maker page; coffee cools faster than in the insulated Clara |
| You sip slowly or get interrupted and want the second cup still hot | Fellow Clara, 24 oz | Smaller 24 oz capacity at a $60.01 higher observed ticket; longer observed delivery window (Oct 5) |
| You hate sludge and want the filter to separate grounds after pressing | ESPRO P3 | Paper-filter upgrade and tea micro-filter are sold separately per the maker page |
| You want guided dosing with lines and a stick plus easy cleanup | Fellow Clara | Only the mesh filter is dishwasher safe per the maker page; the body rinses with warm soapy water |
Specifications that change the decision
| Criterion | ESPRO P3 32 oz Black (B011WTM622) | Fellow Clara 24 oz Matte Black (B094WQ6YT6) |
|---|---|---|
| Brew capacity in observed maker pages | 32 oz brew capacity with 24 oz minimum brew size | 24 oz capacity |
| Filtration mechanism | Patented dual micro-filter with Air Lock Technology; stops extraction after plunge per maker page; paper-filter compatible with filters sold separately | Enhanced mesh filtration per maker page; no dual-basket claim in the observed pages |
| Body and heat story | Transparent extra-thick borosilicate glass carafe in a plastic frame; no vacuum-insulation claim in the observed maker page | Double-wall vacuum-insulated stainless steel body per maker page; keeps brewing temperature steady and coffee hot for later cups |
| Listed dimensions and weight | 6.1 in L x 4.3 in W x 9.51 in H; 1.8 lbs per maker page | 170 mm L x 115 mm W x 200 mm H; 917 g with plastic handle per maker page (784.5 g with walnut handle, a different variant) |
| Materials | Borosilicate glass and polypropylene; BPA, BPS and phthalate-free per maker page | Stainless steel body and filter, BPA-free plastic lid and handle, non-stick PTFE-coated interior that is PFOA-free per maker page |
| Dosing and brew guidance | Maker page ritual is add water, wait four minutes, press and enjoy; 24 oz minimum sets the smallest batch | Ratio lines plus included agitation stick per maker page; manual sets 1:14 as the starting ratio (60 g coffee to 840 g water), 195-205 F water, stir 30 seconds, steep four minutes, then plunge |
| Cleaning | No dishwasher claim in the observed maker page; do not assume dishwasher safety for this variant | Only the mesh filter is dishwasher safe per maker page; body rinses with warm soapy water per manual |
| Observed Amazon US offer, 09/16/2026 | $39.94, In Stock, sold by ESPRO Inc. and shipped from Amazon Fulfillment, delivery Sep 19 | $99.95, sold by Fellow Industries Inc. and shipped from Amazon Fulfillment, delivery Oct 5 as shown; static HTML did not expose an explicit In Stock string for the main variant, so availability is recorded conservatively |
ESPRO P3: the clean-cup everyday pick
The P3 in Black, 32 oz (SKU 1432C-BK) is the press to pick when capacity and clean cups decide. The mechanism is explicit on the maker page: two micro-filters snap together to trap sediment at the bottom while the silicone-gasket seal and Air Lock stop extraction once plunged, so the first cup and the last cup taste closer together than on a single-mesh press. The carafe holds 32 oz with a 24 oz minimum, which covers a full round for two large mugs where the 24 oz Clara would come up short. Materials are listed as borosilicate glass with a polypropylene frame that is BPA, BPS and phthalate-free, and the press is also paper-filter compatible for a pour-over-like cup, with those paper filters and the tea micro-filter sold separately. Its limits are heat and extras: the observed maker page makes no vacuum-insulation claim, so a slow morning cools faster than in the Clara, and the upgrade filters cost extra. The observed listing display is a commercial fact, not a taste test.
Fellow Clara: the insulated design pick
The Clara in Matte Black, 24 oz is the press to pick when heat retention and ritual decide. The mechanism is explicit on the maker page: a double-wall vacuum body holds brewing temperature steady for extraction and keeps later cups warm, enhanced mesh filtration keeps silt out without a dual basket, and the all-direction pour lid serves from any angle. Dosing is guided rather than guessed: ratio lines in the pot plus the included agitation stick, with the manual setting the start at 1:14 (60 g of coarse grounds to 840 g of 195-205 F water), a 30-second stir reaching bottom and sides, a four-minute steep with the filter parked just above the water, then the plunge. Cleanup is rinsing the non-stick PTFE-coated (PFOA-free) interior with warm soapy water while only the mesh filter goes in the dishwasher. Its limits are batch size and ticket: 24 oz against the P3's 32 oz, $99.95 against $39.94 at observed prices, and an Oct 5 delivery window on the observed Amazon page versus Sep 19 for the P3. The observed listing display is a commercial fact, not a taste test.
Ownership, consumables and what to confirm
Neither observed maker page publishes a measured grit-removal or flavor score, so treat the filter stories as design descriptions, not measured results. On consumables, the P3's paper filters are the only recurring extra stated in the observed pages and they are sold separately; price them if you want the pour-over-like option, and note the 18 oz P3 (SKU 1418C-BK) is a different smaller variant, not this 32 oz pick. On the Clara side there is no stated recurring filter purchase in the observed pages; the cost is the ticket and the wait, plus care for the optional walnut parts on other variants, which need occasional food-safe mineral oil per the maker page and do not apply to this Matte Black plastic-handle variant. Re-check price, seller and delivery live before buying: both observed offers ship from Amazon Fulfillment, the P3 sold by ESPRO Inc. and the Clara sold by Fellow Industries Inc., and delivery windows move.
Where to check the exact variants
Compare the ESPRO P3 32 oz Black (B011WTM622) (observed $39.94 In Stock on 09/16/2026, sold by ESPRO Inc. and shipped from Amazon Fulfillment) against the Fellow Clara 24 oz Matte Black (B094WQ6YT6) (observed $99.95 on 09/16/2026, sold by Fellow Industries Inc. and shipped from Amazon Fulfillment, delivery Oct 5 as shown). Confirm the variant on the exact page: 32 oz Black with SKU 1432C-BK on the P3 side, and the 24 oz Matte Black insulated title on the Clara side. If you brew big batches and want the cheapest clean-cup upgrade, take the P3; if you nurse slow mornings and want insulation with a guided ritual, take the Clara.