Buy the DEWALT DWMT73801 108-piece set if you want the lower observed price, a lighter case and quick-release pear-head ratchets with DirectTorque sockets; buy the CRAFTSMAN CMMT12123 105-piece set if you want low-profile 72-tooth ratchets for tight spaces, a documented set of deep and spark-plug sockets, and a full lifetime warranty, and accept the higher observed price. Both sets cover 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. drive work, and both makers specify SAE and Metric 6-point sockets. One wording gap to check before buying: the observed DEWALT Amazon listing titles its exact variant "SAE, 108-Piece (DWMT73801)", while the maker spec block for DWMT73801 lists SAE & Metric, so confirm the exact socket contents on the variant page. On 09/16/2026 the exact DEWALT variant was In Stock on Amazon US at $79.97, shipped from and sold by Amazon.com, and the exact CRAFTSMAN variant was In Stock at $109.00, shipped from and sold by Amazon.com.
Choose by your situation
| Situation | Set to consider | Main tradeoff |
|---|---|---|
| You want a starter set for home and light auto work at the lowest observed price | DEWALT DWMT73801 | 1-year limited maker warranty vs lifetime; confirm SAE/Metric contents on the variant page |
| You work in tight engine bays and want the thinnest ratchet heads | CRAFTSMAN CMMT12123 | Costs $29.03 more at observed prices; heavier case at 14.64 lb |
| You need deep sockets and spark-plug sockets spelled out in the set | CRAFTSMAN CMMT12123 | 105 pieces vs 108; no removable accessory case called out |
| You carry the set often and want the lighter box with a bit driver and hex keys | DEWALT DWMT73801 | No spark-plug sockets documented in the observed specs; shorter maker warranty |
Specifications that change the decision
| Criterion | DEWALT DWMT73801 (B00U0P0GHM) | CRAFTSMAN CMMT12123 (B0D5CTCC2V) |
|---|---|---|
| Piece count | 108 per maker and listing | 105 per maker and listing |
| Drive sizes | 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. per maker and listing | 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. per maker and listing |
| Measurement systems | Maker spec block: SAE & Metric; observed Amazon title says "SAE, 108-Piece", so confirm contents | SAE & Metric per maker and listing |
| Ratchets | Two pear-head ratchets per maker; quick-release 72-tooth gear per maker features | Two low-profile 72-tooth ratchets per maker; 5-degree arc swing, head up to 25% thinner per maker |
| Sockets | 6-point with DirectTorque anti-rounding per maker; 1/4-in. drive SAE and Metric sizes listed | 6-point per maker; 44 standard plus 26 deep sockets, 2 spark-plug sockets per maker includes list |
| Bits, keys and drivers | Bit driver with anti-slip vinyl grip, hex keys, screwdriver bits and extensions shown per maker | 16 short-arm hex keys, bit driver, 10 specialty bits, 2 extensions, universal joint and adapter per maker includes list |
| Material and finish | Chrome vanadium steel, polished chrome finish per maker; listing says polished | Chrome vanadium steel, full polish chrome per maker and listing |
| Case | Hard case with removable accessory case per maker | Blow-molded case with metal hinges per maker; shaped to fit CRAFTSMAN metal storage boxes |
| Case size and weight | 16.2 x 12.4 x 4.6 in, 11.38 lb per maker | 17.0 x 15.0 x 4.1 in, 14.64 lb per maker |
| Warranty | 1-year limited warranty per maker | Full lifetime warranty per maker and listing |
| Observed Amazon US offer, 09/16/2026 | $79.97, In Stock, shipped from and sold by Amazon.com; 9 new offers from $79.97 | $109.00, In Stock, shipped from and sold by Amazon.com; 4 new offers from $109.00; Style NEW 105 Piece Set selected |
DEWALT DWMT73801: the lighter value pick
The DWMT73801 (108 pieces, 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. drive) is the set to pick when price and portability decide. The mechanism is explicit in the maker page: two pear-head ratchets with a quick-release 72-tooth gear, 6-point sockets with DirectTorque geometry against fastener rounding, a knurled control ring, and a bit driver plus hex keys, bits and extensions in a hard case with a removable accessory section, at 11.38 lb. Its limits are warranty and wording: the maker gives a 1-year limited warranty against the CRAFTSMAN lifetime terms, and the observed Amazon title centers an "SAE"-labeled variant while the maker spec block claims SAE & Metric, so verify the socket list on the exact-variant page before buying. The listing showed 4.8 out of 5 stars across 7,551 ratings with an Amazon's Choice badge, which is a listing display, not a test result.
CRAFTSMAN CMMT12123: the access-and-warranty pick
The CMMT12123 (105 pieces, 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. drive) is the set to pick when access and coverage decide. The mechanism is explicit: low-profile 72-tooth ratchets with a 5-degree arc swing and heads up to 25% thinner for confined spaces, a documented includes list of 44 standard sockets, 26 deep sockets, 2 spark-plug sockets, 16 hex keys, 2 extensions, a universal joint, an adapter, a bit driver and 10 specialty bits, in a blow-molded case with metal hinges that fits CRAFTSMAN metal storage boxes. Its limits are price and weight: at $109.00 observed it costs $29.03 more than the DEWALT, and the case weighs 14.64 lb against 11.38 lb. The full lifetime warranty is the strongest ownership argument here. The listing showed 4.8 out of 5 stars across 303 ratings with an Amazon's Choice badge, which is a listing display, not a test result.
Ratchets, case and what it costs to own
Both sets use 72-tooth ratchets, so the practical split is head profile against versatility: the CRAFTSMAN low-profile heads exist for fasteners you can barely reach, while the DEWALT pear-head quick-release ratchets with DirectTorque sockets exist for fast everyday turning with less rounding. Neither maker publishes a torque-test or durability-test method in the observed pages, so treat the gear and finish stories as design descriptions backed by the stated warranties, not as measured results. Ownership math is simple: the CRAFTSMAN full lifetime warranty outlasts the DEWALT 1-year limited warranty on paper, while the DEWALT box is about 3.3 lb lighter and $29.03 cheaper at observed prices. Compare only the observed set prices; sockets do not consume anything per use.
Where to check the exact variants
Compare the DEWALT DWMT73801, 108-piece 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. drive (B00U0P0GHM) (observed In Stock at $79.97 on 09/16/2026, shipped from and sold by Amazon.com) against the CRAFTSMAN CMMT12123, 105-piece 1/4-in. and 3/8-in. drive, NEW 105 Piece Set (B0D5CTCC2V) (observed In Stock at $109.00 on 09/16/2026, shipped from and sold by Amazon.com). Amazon links in this guide are affiliate links: qualifying purchases may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. If value and carry weight matter most, take the DEWALT after confirming the socket contents; if tight-space access, deep sockets and lifetime warranty matter most, take the CRAFTSMAN.